Member since 2025
I bought the Handyman Butt Plug for the first time, and I've been longing for this type of fisting. Size: Medium/Large, 75% soft, color: Natural Tan. This fist is about the same as my wife's, so I can enjoy doing things I can't ask my wife to do. My wife's fake fist easily penetrated my anus and entered my rectum, and the pleasure at that moment went through my whole body and hit my brain directly, making me scream like a woman. If you want to have masochistic sex, this is the Butt Plug for you. I've already ordered the XXXL, and I'm looking for even more pleasure.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
Love it! Recommended for aspiring fisters. Several friends recommended it, so I ordered one. Following recommendations of other reviewers, I ordered the medium firm in size XL. Some suggest "order the next size above what you can take" - well, I was close to taking the XL, but the jump to 3XL is just a bit too big to start with. But in the last month I managed to take the XL without any smaller warmup toys, and I DID order the 3XL for the future. A 2XL in-between the XL and 3XL - say about 11" or so - might be nice.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
Ich hab die xl bestellt und muss sagen mein gieriges Loch verschlang den Plug ohne große Mühe .Jetzt werde ich mir die xxxl Version holen um mein Loch an was großes zu trainieren
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
It is one big hand! Have next size down and I take that easily This is a wonderful five finger challenge
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
A friend said his hands are same size as Handyman XL. I haven't taken him (yet). Based on other reviews, I ordered Medium Firm in size XL. After some warmup with smaller toys, I quite enjoyed my ride. Recommended!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
I just got the 3XL Fist Plug as a gift and then wore it all night at the Kit Kat Club in Berlin! And it just feels insanely awesome! When sitting, like walking, or even when dancing, to have the feeling of being permanently fisted. And that too with a fist that is even bigger than I'm normally used to. Especially the circumference of the wrist is decisive, because this determines how far the asshole is permanently stretched! I can especially recommend wearing it sitting on a bar stool during a casual conversation at the bar. My companion visibly enjoyed the fact that I moved more and more restlessly on the bar stool and felt permanently fisted without having to bend one finge only!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
Great plug, well made and great sensations. I only wish I’d of gotten a larger size
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2025
Honestly this guy rocks my world. It is quite the stretch, I usually don't have problems with bigger toys but actually had to warm up for this! The depth is perfect. My only complaint is that there isn't a 5XL because if the 2XL taught me anything it's that this will feel small in a year if you're anything like me and keep craving a bigger stretch.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
always the excellent quality and finish of the brand. I'm a fan. the texture is just right to push to the limits without hurting yourself. super fast delivery in france. the diameter can be scary but it's ultimately easier than some others of the brand with a smaller diameter. in short it's really incredible sensations when it fits completely.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
This is an excellent toy. I got the XL which is the size of a good sized hand. The texture is amazing, the fullness and the stretch really satisfied.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Just got my 4XL yesterday. Love it! Only thing that could make it better would be if I had a fuck machine that I could strap it to!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Wow! Took me about a week to get it all in. Now I’m ready to go bigger!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Love this toy! The XL is almost exactly the size of my actual hand. I had originally ordered the 75% soft but quickly ordered a second one in med firm. The med firm is a much more realistic feel with very little give just like a real hand. So if you're up to a bit more of a challenge, get the med firm.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Size up, and get medium firm- I bought one size larger than I thought I could handle and I'm glad I did, the max circumference passes quickly, and the hand shape is a more forgiving than a cyclindar. I'm glad I selected the medium firm, it feels like a realist, slightly-flexed hand, and the knuckles feel very real. The sensation as it pops in, literally makes my eyes roll back in my head. I like that it stays put once in.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Its the most beautiful toy i have ever seen. The details are stunning. Not expected to be that realistic.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
What an amazing ride, I was worried at first but the hand just grabbed my inside and pulled me down with a warm embrace
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
I got the XL 75% firm. When it popped in it was the most amazing experience I have had. It created the perfect gape as well. I highly recommend this plug. It’s my new favorite toy.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
When I purchased this particular butt plug, I knew I was getting a smaller toy (Note: my wife and I have been playing with some of the MrHankey XXL-XXXL sized toys for at least 2 years, and my ass loves all of them, so as a point of reference, I can open up to approximately 13-14 inches in circumference!). When we started playing, she was able to use her hands more (all I can say is one and two hand fisting is out of this world if you do it right), but her arthritis drove us to the bigger toys. So, I bought this toy as it closely approximates the size of my wife's hand...all I can say is wow, I came almost immediately, and I came frequently in our first session with this toy!! I currently own 15 MrHankey toys and this one is my new favorite. Thank you MrHankey!!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
This is the first Hankey butt item I've ordered that was smaller than I expected -- it's well-made and comfortable, and my hole could swallow it immediately, but depending how piggy you are, the next size up might be the best plug to start with. Oink!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
Perfect
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
I love to be fisted but I've found it harder for me to fist myself lately. I guess the older I get the less flexible I've gotten. The XL handyman was better than expected. It gives me such a great stretch and hits all the right spots.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2024
The XXXXL is so so so large. Amazing toy I just suggest really doing research before getting the biggest!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Great toy. Love the feeling and size. Purchased 4X in 75% firm. Love the feeling as it slides in. It’s amazing!!! Highly recommend!!!!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
I got the XXXL in 75% firm, my first ever hankey purchase and I'm in love. I was impressed right away by the quality. It was the largest toy I've ever taken, but I was so turned on by the realism of the hands that I stretched wide open and took it to the base on my first attempt! Everything from the girth of the meaty palm to the detail and texture on the thick fingers made me horny, I watched the handyman punch in and out of me until my legs were shaking. Can't recommend this enough, this toy makes me want to transform my hole with larger and larger toys, and I think I only trust Hankeys Toys to do the job.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
This toy is amazing
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
4XL Handyman 75%: it’s really really big. Up to this point I have only used 3.5 inch wide toys so I got this to practice for a double fisting. I used it for about 30 min to warm up and got to the main knuckles. That pointer finger knuckle is like Mount Everest! I had to turn it every which way and wiggle but finally got past it. Once you get past that one knuckle it’s smooth sailing. I was not able to bottom out though as I hit a wall about 1 inch from the bottom. Only the wrist was sticking out so I still claim it as a win. It’s all I think about now lol!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Also ordered the XL 75% soft for my boyfriend. So that he could use this as an everyday toy.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Handyman butt plug 4XL 75% soft in the colour black. I gave this as a gift to my boyfriend because he loves fisting. When it arrived he couldn't believe how thick this plug was and that the details look so realistic. It is certainly going to be a challenge but defenitely a fun one!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Fun toy. Can’t quite complete the mission on my 4x Handyman
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
I was pleasantly surprised when I got the package. Entered the 75% soft XXL into my arse. Got very happy. Customer service with items of this nature is impossible to sort through but rest assured the people at Mr Hankey have a thorough understanding of their products and absolutely will find an answer for those tough questions you may have. All my future toys will be purchased with these guys. I'm getting back to having three hands!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
The Handyman Butt Plug 4XL was a perfect fix for my backdoor! Since my wife's little hands began servicing my backdoor it was time to move on to a much bigger hand job! This plug filled my gape and stretched it out as it disappeared inside of me. Just a little wiggling around the thumb knuckle and is slid right in. I could feel the tips of the fingers tickling my insides. Great job, hands up!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Love how thick this toy is! Makes me feel beyond full! Love every single toy I've ever bought from Hankey's!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Very comfortable and realistic feeling version of an extra large mit. It’s very challenging for an intermediate player like me getting ready to fist a large hand with confidence. A good training toy.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
ordered 4xl and got it sent, couldn't wait...when I received it I immediately had to try to get it up and wow what a feeling when it slipped past the knuckles and all the way up, I was about to pass out what a feeling.. .. great toy
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
This has quickly become my favorite toy. I haven't quite gotten over all the knuckles but the stretch it gives my hungry hole is incredible. I've never experienced my hole throbbing and aching for days after playing with a toy prior to this one. I love the details in the fingers and I was a bit worried that the medium firm would be to form but it is perfect.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Amazing detail, this is the perfect training tool for me in my journey for the perfect stretch, without going too deep. I'm starting to have quite a collection of your wonderful toys and am looking forward to my next best friend. And thank you for the great service.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
I’m just starting to experiment with the pleasures of fisting and the small one is the perfect size for starters. Love it so far
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
“Holy cow,” Part 2. I like to add that my EXTRA LARGE (I first said “large”) Handyman tends to fall out my hole because of its size and shape. While I “practiced” to keep to keep him inside my hole,, I thought of what Square Peg Toys said of its similar product, “The Open Hand”: “it’s important to remember that it does not move like a hand, nor does it have a brain attached to get it to coax open a hole like a talented Top could.” This made me wonder whether Mr Hankey could make a remotely controlled mechanical hand that can simulate a real fisting. If so, I will buy you one, or two, as soon as they’re offered for sale.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
“Holy cow, it’s bigger than my hand!” That was my first thought when my large “Handyman” arrived. Its large knuckles looked so awesome, that to fully insert him in my hole seemed so tantalizingly challenging! Its medium firmness, the only one offered, however, made the challenge easier than I expected (or hoped for) when I managed to fully insert it in my cavernous hole during my first “session” with Handyman. (And he went in with an “electrifying pop”!) Though I’ve yet to be fisted by a real hand, I would like to imagine that Handyman offers the next best thing to a real fisting.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Hankey’s Toys are well worth every dime. I’ve been eyeballing their ads for quite sometime and finally decided to give them a try. Not only were they true to advertisement, but they were thorough in communication about the order and delivery. Even more exciting, is that my order arrived early! They also offer bday discounts and have so many selections to choose from- with the majority giving you the option of sizes up to 3XL (and some even offer 4XL). Please believe the hype! By far…Hankey’s is (now) my new favorite place to shop for “butthole munchies.”
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Fantastic toy feels lifelike
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Very high quality! The Medium/Large was a little smaller than I thought but that was my bad and it still performs great!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
This one has been fun.. Great product as always...
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
XL size is a bit smaller than I thought it would be, my hand is a xl in glove size, and this plug is smaller than that. None the less it's still a fun tool to have in the box. It's very detailed and freakishly realistic.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Bought 4XL and after though it was too big but it's the perfect size. It didn't work as a butt plug alone so I ordered a two more to get triple fisted and on my lord it feels so goood, after using these for a while I started using bowling pins
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2023
Too small but feels good. Need the next size up.
Member since 2022
This toy is great as an opener for bigger toys overall it's great only one flaw is quiet bendy in the softer option.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Sometimes I want it twice a day. XXXL and XXXXL are the best. It could be longer and also double fisting with two hands together.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
XXXL Med-firm is the way to go! At 12" Circumference at Knuckles, it's a bit of a challenge but oh so worth it once it slips in. Deeply satisfying and now one of my favorites to enjoy.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Whow! What a ride, working the 4XL into my hole. I love the fullness when he occupies my rectal cavity+. Thanks, Mr Hankey’s!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
What a beast! I underestimated the size of the handy man but I have an insatiable hole so I'm up for the challenge. It's feels incredible and is the perfect firmness. Cannot wait to get to whole thing inside me.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Perfect fist toy. I don't know how well it works as a butt plug, but as a stretching toy, it is incredible. I ordered the 4XL in 75% soft. I find that that that is the perfect amount of softness/firmness for when you want to size up. It's as if the toy helps you out, flexing and giving and expanding in just the right way, and it feels oh so amazing. I did not order the vac u lock attachment hole, but the base is strong enough to sort of suction cup itself to the floor of the shower with little-to-no slippage. Be prepared for the stretch of your life, and go for a size bigger than you think you'll need. You'll be glad you did.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Nice toy but doesn’t work as a daily buttplug which i bought it fo,r because it pops out almost right away. Oxballs makes a daily fist shaped buttplug which stays in that you might want to model a version from for people like me who want a daily buttplug. All your other toys I bought are especially the (has to be)gummy- bear soft Goliath.
Member since 2022
Wow! I love this. I think I might order the next bigger size soon.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Absolutely love everything about it. I just wish that there was a mix between this and stump! Some forearm would be nuce
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
This was great! Nice and full feeling . I got the XL. I wish maybe longer with forearm?
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Great size and shape. just wish there was an extra two inches on the wrist. I also didnt see a vac u lock option which i would like as I wanted to use this in the shower and have it stick to the wall.
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Oh wow!!! Best toy ever!! I bought the XL 75% soft. What I like personally is lots of stretch without needing a ton of length to get there. I love how this is tapered, starting narrow, then in a short distance getting very thick!! SO GOOD! The pop over the last set of knuckles is mind blowing!! I can’t wait to get myself to the next size up!!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Quick delivery. :-) Amazing quality and feel. I received it and tried it on the same day. Wow!!! What a stretch!!! Once you get used to it, you could ride it hard in and out and the sensation is amazing! When I'm ready for something bigger, I will order the next size! Love it!!!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Holly fuck I have my XXXL 75% SOFT the handyman name make this dildo go into you imagination Congratulations Hankeys please I can wait for a
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Holly fuck I have my XXXL 75% SOFT the handyman name make this dildo go into you imagination Congratulations Hankeys please I can wait for a
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Bigger than I expected ... bigger satisfaction
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
Beautifully crafted, perfectly detailed, male hand. Realistically lifelike. Slides in and opens you up with surprising ease. Excellent fisting practice toy. Highly recommended!
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
I should have got the largest one my butt swallowed this one hole !!!! Butt very nice
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
I should have got the largest one my butt swallowed this one hole !!!! Butt very nice
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
I should have got the largest one my butt swallowed this one hole !!!! Butt very nice
Yes, I recommend this product.
Member since 2022
I want this one in elbov deep, pleas...
Yes, I recommend this product.
HANDYMAN - MD/LG
Overall length:
7.75" 19.69cm
Insertable length:
6.5" 16.51cm
Texture:
Realistic skin with light vein detail
Strapon Ring Size:
N/A
Circumference at Finger Knuckles:
5.75" 14.61cm
Circumference at Knuckles:
8.5" 21.59cm
Circumference at Wrist:
6.4" 16.26cm
HANDYMAN - XL
Overall length:
8.9" 22.61cm
Insertable length:
7.75" 19.69cm
Texture:
Realistic skin with light vein detail
Strapon Ring Size:
N/A
Circumference at Finger Knuckles:
7.25" 18.42cm
Circumference at Knuckles:
10.25" 26.04cm
Circumference at Wrist:
7.6" 19.30cm
HANDYMAN - XXXL
Overall length:
10.25" 26.04cm
Insertable length:
9" 22.86cm
Texture:
Realistic skin with light vein detail
Strapon Ring Size:
N/A
Circumference at Finger Knuckles:
8.75" 22.23cm
Circumference at Knuckles:
12" 30.48cm
Circumference at Wrist:
8.8" 22.35cm
HANDYMAN - 4XL
Overall length:
11.5" 29.21cm
Insertable length:
9.9" 25.15cm
Texture:
Realistic skin with light vein detail
Strapon Ring Size:
N/A
Circumference at Finger Knuckles:
9.3" 23.62cm
Circumference at Knuckles:
14.1" 35.81cm
Circumference at Wrist:
10.25" 26.04cm
A NOTE ABOUT INTERNATIONAL ORDERS: Customers are responsible for paying all duties and taxes for their respective countries
Return Policy: Due to the nature of our products, there are no returns on orders unless defective. Please pay attention to the dimensions carefully and don't let your eyes get greedier than your hole! Contact me if you have any questions prior to placing your order.
